The UK government has accepted recommendations from a UK-first independent review to tackle potential bias in the design and use of medical devices.
The Department of Health and Social Care commissioned senior health experts to identify potential biases in these devices and recommend how to tackle them. The review followed concerns that pulse oximeters – widely used during the COVID-19 pandemic to monitor blood oxygen levels – were not as accurate for patients with darker skin tones, which could have led to delays in treatment if dangerously low oxygen levels in patients with darker skin tone were missed. However, the review found no evidence from studies in the NHS of this differential performance affecting care.
The government has made several commitments on the back of the report, including ensuring that pulse oximeter devices used in the NHS can be used safely across a range of skin tones, and removing racial bias from data sets used in clinical studies.
Minister of state, Andrew Stephenson said: “I am hugely grateful to Professor Dame Margaret Whitehead for carrying out this important review.
“Making sure the healthcare system works for everyone, regardless of ethnicity, is paramount to our values as a nation. It supports our wider work to create a fairer and simpler NHS.”
Action that is being taken to overcome potential disparities in the performance of medical devices includes:
- Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) now requests that approval applications for new medical devices describe how they will address bias
- NHS guidance has been updated to highlight potential limitations of pulse oximeter devices on patients with darker skin tone
- The National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) is currently accepting funding applications for research into smarter oximeters.
The government has said it will also:
- Work with the MHRA to ensure regulations for medical devices are safe for patients, regardless of their background, while allowing more innovative products to be placed on the UK market. This includes a commitment to ensure pulse oximeters are safe and effective for all patients, with work underway to mitigate any inaccuracy in the devices.
- Drive forward work to remove racial bias in datasets, including ensuring diverse skin tones are included in data used by researchers for clinical studies.
- Support ongoing work with NHS England to upskill clinical professionals on issues including health equity.
- Work with partners to improve transparency of data used in the development of medical devices using Artificial Intelligence (AI), as well as AI products which influence clinical decisions.
The government appointed Professor Dame Margaret Whitehead, professor of public health at the University of Liverpool, to lead the review. Professor Whitehead has for many years led the work of the World Health Organisation’s Collaborating Centre for Policy Research on the Determinants of Health Equity.
The medical devices review focused on three areas – optical devices such as pulse oximeters, AI-enabled devices, and polygenic risk scores (PRS) in genomics.
Professor Dame Margaret Whitehead, chair of the review said: “The advance of AI in medical devices could bring great benefits, but it could also bring harm through inherent bias against certain groups in the population, notably women, people from ethnic minorities and disadvantaged socio-economic groups.
“Our review reveals how existing biases and injustices in society can unwittingly be incorporated at every stage of the lifecycle of AI-enabled medical devices, and then magnified in algorithm development and machine learning.
“Our recommendations therefore call for system-wide action, requiring full government support. The UK would take the lead internationally if it incorporated equity in AI-enabled medical devices into its Global AI Safety initiatives.”
The review also recommended ways of developing bias-free medical devices in the future and to improve standards globally.
Dr June Raine, MHRA chief executive, added: “The MHRA acknowledges that inequities can exist within medical devices and we therefore welcome the publication of Dame Whitehead’s independent review.
“We are highly committed to ensuring equitable access to safe, effective and high-quality medical devices for all individuals, and the recommendations set out in this report will support and strengthen the impact of our ongoing work in this area.
“We are committed to working collaboratively with Government, regulatory bodies, healthcare professionals and stakeholders to address these issues effectively.”
